Annotated Bibliography
Research Proposal
First Draft of the Paper
Final Draft of the Paper
(due dates for these papers are in the syllabus schedule)
First, it is important to know exactly what a
research paper in history is. For our purposes, a research
project for writing history at this level must aim at more than
just a recounting of events. The paper must deal with the
meaning of a chosen episode or topic. Hence, you will be putting
together an account of some event, or trend, or idea, or theme,
but you will also aim to decode or explain the topic you have
chosen. Many historians will tell you that the "What" question
of a research paper must be accompanied by the question "So
What?" What makes your topic important, historically
significant? What does your conclusion lead you to posit?
What is the meaning of the "story" or "profile" you have put
together.
A research project of any kind is always divided into several
stages. The most basic division is easy: research vs. writing.
But the sophistication of a real research paper in history at
the upper-level makes it necessary for you to break down the
project into even more divisions. And this same
sophistication needed to produce such a paper will require you
to be extremely intentional with your METHODS of research and
writing.
The first stage of your journey will be to select a topic. This
is tricky business. The topic has to be within our course
subject matter, naturally. But at this point, you don't know the
things we will study, since you haven't had the full course yet!
So you have to triangulate, to listen carefully and ask
questions when we talk about topics in class and individually,
to look over the whole syllabus carefully, and to think about
what kinds of sources are out there.
Next, you will produce an extensive Annotated
Bibliography. This will consist of far more than
just listing a few sources. For one thing, it will require you
to find both primary and secondary materials. We will discuss
the meaning of these categories in class. It will also require
you to cover the ground for the topic you choose. You must not
be satisfied with a primary source and a few secondary articles.
You must produce a list of all the writing you can find that
touches on your topic. And for the purposes of the assigned
bibliography, you have to do with a topic in mind.
Complicated? Yes. Difficult? Yes. But finding out a
multiplicity of sources and approaches is crucial. This process
will lead you to think about your topic and craft your own
examination of it.
Quick note on the preceding: if you can't find primary sources
for your topic, you can't write a paper successfully. This
means, for this course and most courses, that you are better off
to start by finding some fund of primary sources and peruse
those to see if they "suggest" a topic that "speaks" to you.
Again, we will go over this in class.
The second stage is to write a proposal. This will include a
hard and practical decision about exactly what you intend to
write about. We are no longer look at "The Battle of the Bulge"
or "Queen Elizabeth I." We are looking to define a very
specific episode or aspect and explore it thoroughly. So
as opposed to the previous two general topics, you will looking
for something like "German Covert Measures During the Battle of
the Bulge" or "The Tax Policies of Queen Elizabeth I."
Just examples.
The next stage is the drafting of the paper. We will be talking
a lot about the specific form of the paper in class. But for
now, think hard about how one can keep track of multiple
sources, evaluate the primary sources, develop ideas about the
topic... and write it all in a coherent, readable form! You must
have a good method for this, and we will talk about some useable
methods in class.
The final stage is the editing and revision of your first draft.
That first draft should "perfect"! But after you have some
time to think about and to read my comments, and perhaps talk to
me about it, you will see that you can improve your writing,
clarify your ideas, and sharpen the paper a great deal.
We will be discussing methods for drafting the paper in class
at great length. You will need to adopt a careful and
thought-out method, such as using notecards, or a ring binder,
and using this method in a coherent and detailed way. The
"hit-or-miss" method will not be allowed.
This list might give you a sense of the level of grammatical and
stylistic level at which I will be looking at your paper:
EXAM AND PAPER EVALUATION
SHEET